No offence Justafan but how can you say Herbert is starting to look good when his edge got absolutely torn apart last week. I thought defence was supposed to be one of his strong points but jeez they looked bad
No offence Justafan but how can you say Herbert is starting to look good when his edge got absolutely torn apart last week. I thought defence was supposed to be one of his strong points but jeez they looked bad
Fair enough mate. Appreciate the response. That respect goes both ways.
I wouldn't say I'm throwing a rumour out there though. Had I'd just said he wasn't injured then we'd know what the next questions would be anyway. Saying he isn't avaialble for selection is a fact and something someone could reasonably conclude based on him not playing ISC, and not part of the injury report. Not exactly an insider scoop, or a rumour.
Fair call re people pretending to be insiders (god I hate that term) but I think the right to be taken seriously with respect to any insight is something that is earned here. Unfortunately the reality is that some detail can't always be given because putting it in the public eye creates risk - especially when journalists and others looking to capitalise on the details are reading the forum. Some forum members do appreciate information that answers their questions without needing to know the full story. Those who PM'd me were people I've known for years on the forum and trust - I'm far too boring to be demanding attention from the wider forum about anything really
I'm not really sure what the best solution is mate but I'm comfortable continuing to share the (very little) information that I think the forum would get value or insight from. It's not always going to be as much as we'd all like but I hope hope that people can appreciate and understand why that is.
Really do appreciate your response and explanation MT. Now give us Schuster pls
Last edited by Hail Sezer; 22-04-21 at 08:13 PM.
Someone mentioned how Tino had missed 22 tackles. There’s a big difference between some missed tackles and others and most of his aren’t bad ones as they are him putting a big shot on or running out of the line and bumping off the attacker
I would like Tino on an edge too (or in 13 although i think McIntyre will own that eventually) ... the proctologist does nothing for me and with McIntyre, Fermor, Stone and Farmer to name just a few mobile young backrowers then I am hoping that they get their chance at some stage. MoFo, Wallace, Joliffe, Lisone and the elusive Ese'ese more than cover the middles ... didn't add Whitbread who is a level below the others I feel.
Four reasons to escape to Queensland: Sun, Surf, Sand & the Titans.
We need halves and we need them quick because we can’t waste another year. With Taylor’s money and the other 600k we have sitting around we need to go hard at at least one top tier half. We should give Greg Marzhew a run sometime during this year and Sefton as well.
Priorities 1 and 2
Darryl Clarke at 9, Shaun Johnson at 6.
I haven’t really heard of Daryl Clarke outside of here. Can someone give me a rundown on what he is like as a player
3W 4L with an incredible start to the year with our injuries.
I’m lowering my expectations completely now.
And we still have a lot of Brennan list cloggers.
Mal and Justin need to continue to radically overhaul our roster.
Can anybody remember how well we went last year with Stone replacing the biter? Now Stone imho is not a Tino or even a McIntyre but that right side FUNCTIONED without Proctor ... surely somebody out there recognizes this too, I’m tired of repeating myself.
Four reasons to escape to Queensland: Sun, Surf, Sand & the Titans.
My question
Was Corey Thompson held before Reynolds and Campbell Graham put him in touch.
I thought he was held.
Also AJ made a half break early in the second half and got held down for ages which should’ve been a 6 again at least, potentially even a sinbin. But of course nothing