I'll be extremely disappointed if we see Elgey go to Manly. Firstly, I don't see what we would gain from it, I'm sure they cant afford to pay his large salary and the only player I would want back from them is Brian Kelly but they won't let him go. Secondly, I think he has been a little hard done by being dropped because he "can't manage the team" when Garth has been saying all year that it's Ash's team. Sure his defence has been bad but he's had several different second rowers outside him which has clearly not helped the situation. His attack has shown glimpses of getting back to where it should be (like that nice grubber he put in for Don to score against penrith and the cut out ball he threw to Don against manly but he ran into Gordon..). Cartwright has been far worse than Kane in my opinion this season but everyone seems to get juggled around to fit him in. Surely dropping him to learn how to defend like second rower would be more beneficial because he's not a long term eighth option.
Agree with you Shamrock about Peachy but where do we play him? He's not really an organiser for the halves, too small for centre and doesn't want to play a utility role.. Man I would love to have any one of their forwards in our pack though