Prince among thin field of halfbacks
THERE is a century-old adage that you need a match-winning halfback to have any chance of winning a rugby league premiership.
If that is the case, the NRL grand final this season should be contested between the Gold Coast Titans and Sydney Roosters.
Moving into the finals, the NRL will offer up two exceptional halfbacks in Scott Prince and Mitchell Pearce.
Below them there appears to be a chasing field of skilled yet modest No. 7s that six other teams will pin their premiership hopes on in September.
Former Balmain and New Zealand halfback Gary Freeman yesterday stuck his chin out and courageously rated the halfbacks.
He understandably had Prince first ahead of Pearce and then, surprisingly, Penrith's Luke Walsh.
They were followed, in order, by Ben Hornby (St George Illawarra), Chris Sandow (Souths), Peter Wallace (Brisbane), Robert Lui (Wests Tigers), Brett Seymour (Warriors), Trent Hodkinson (Manly), Josh McCrone (Canberra) and Jeff Robson (Parramatta).
Asked if there was a shallow depth in the halfback ranks this year because Cooper Cronk and Johnathan Thurston would not be playing in September, former Australian halfback Greg Alexander said: "I think there are a lot of halfbacks at a similar level.
"A lot of them have plenty of good things in their game but are also lacking in other areas. Apart from a couple of standouts, the difference between the others is very little.
"We should remember the two top halfbacks aren't there.
"And in a few cases, the chief playmakers at clubs are the five-eighths."
Freeman rated Prince an eight out of 10 and Pearce a 7 1/2 out of 10.
Co-incidentally, Prince and Pearce go head to head on Monday night at the SFS. But Prince will enter the finals as the standout halfback.
"The halfback issue is more about the different styles they all play and the different styles each coach wants," Freeman said.
"I think a lot of coaches move young halfbacks, which doesn't help their development. They come through as a halfback then are thrown into hooker. It doesn't help."
Freeman offered a few observations about the current batch of halfbacks.
"Scott Prince has an all-round game," Freeman said. "You can tell he is in total control of his team. At other clubs, other players like the lock or five-eighth help out. But Prince is in charge at the Titans.
"Mitchell Pearce has a great running game and a tremendous kicking game. I would like to see him take on the line a little more.
"Chris Sandow has only played about 30 games. He can do anything. How much better can he get?
"Luke Walsh has a great kicking game and a great short passing game. He can put blokes through holes.
"Josh McCrone is super quick.
"Jeff Robson finds it hard because there are so many others at Parramatta who can dominate, like Jarryd Hayne and Feleti Mateo.
"Robert Lui has really stood up over the past few weeks since he came back from injury. I think he will explode in the finals."
Walsh and Sandow will clash tonight at CUA Stadium. Panthers half Walsh has enjoyed enormous success this year with 26 try assists from his kicking game, the best in the NRL.
Robson and Lui clash on Sunday at a sold-out Parramatta Stadium.
Lui produced his finest performance of the season so far in Wests Tigers' 43-18 win over Penrith last Sunday at Campbelltown.
"I know I am capable of being the first-grade halfback," Lui said.
Hodkinson and Seymour will meet at Brookvale tomorrow afternoon in another vitally important game.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au