Search:

Apparently he was mentoring someone from a NRLW side.

Or Josh Dugan!

Cheers mate. I remember we were discussed as being interested in him. I do wonder just how much we went after him considering he was already settled up here, but it doesn't really matter now.
If we...

Yep, he did more today than our useless halves have done all year. I know Milford has been average for a few years but he was a better option than the crap we have, and still have heading in to...

Yep he has been outstanding.

This 1000% HS.

No issues with JC at FB and Brimson moving in, but who will be the other half. We are kidding ourselves if we think that combination will take us far, and it's not fair to put that pressure on JC...

Respect your opinion mate but Fogarty is not NRL standard and that is a case of re-arranging the deckchairs on the Titanic. (sorry to use your name T).

Yeah that seems the unfortunate reality, as well as halves, now that we signed no one who was on the market. I just hate the thought of next season being a write off which I think it will be. Last...

Yeah but this bloke is behind three. I'd suggest our hooker problems remain unresolved.

No more than 550-600k for the minutes he plays.

I don't think he was much at NRL level when he was picked for Origin - how he was picked is one of life's great mysteries.
He was very average in hit ups considering his size and the much smaller...

I agree and have been saying this for a while. I obviously hope he kills it but so many do not make it when they get with the big boys. Just crazy to pin all our hopes on it.
Just have a read of...

Brimson you want as a FB, which I agree with. Boyd and Fogarty failed. Turner unproven. Weaver still got his training wheels on. JC very unproven in the halves. Peachey, no as a half.
A very...

For me it is no so much the investment. It is simply, if we cut Ash, are the remaining halves better options. For me the answer is no. That is the only reason I would retain him as things stand right...

This 100%. I would be happy to let Taylor go for sure, but all the potential signings were not pursued and our existing options are as you put it.

- - - Updated - - -



I think we are worse...

Interesting comment that Ash was sensational on the weekend. A few of us on here would beg to differ.
If he goes to Canberra, he would follow the steps of Ryan James. That's worked out well.

^^
Great post mate and summarises things well.
You have listed some options after 2022, but what concerns me is that next seasons team is looking essentially the same as now. That wouldn't be good.

The Ese Ese signing is right up there with the Shannon Boyd signing as the worst ever.

I agree and would say he is on nothing like what KP is on. Sign neither in my book, although Fogs would offer slightly more as a QCup depth layer than KP does.

If it is Fogarty, I wouldn't have extended him either. A shocking kicking game and offers little in attack.
I thought Fogs extended a week or so back.

We find money for Proctor but let all the halves that were on the market go elsewhere. Now, before someone tells me Proctor is cheaper than the halves that were available, we had Ash's money plus...

And people were worrying about signing Ash again.
No to Watson. Able to play a few positions but none of them well enough to justify his price.

In my opinion we can rule out Boyd and Fogs as they are not going to take us anywhere. So we have Sexton and an unknown Turner. That is why I am hedging my bets with Taylor. I have bagged him as much...

As it stands right now I sort of agree with you. Ash and Sexton looked ok last week and they are a better pair than the other fails we have had this season. I'd like to see how they go over the next...