Nah sorry that's stupid, Ash literally was forced to come off for a HIA. It's the rules that he must come off, not just because he's "soft". Plus not a good comparison as Ponga was dog**** today.
Printable View
Ponga was dog shotted. Stayed on for another 5 mins. Then went for HIA. Came back on got two more dog shots and stayed on. All three way heavier contact then that shot on Taylor. Ash got up and walked straight off. Soft as pudding.
The point I am making is Ponga is a winner. Taylor is not even a competitor which is a worry when the game is on the line.
I don't understand people still bagging Taylor. Yes he is on 1 million dollars and he has struggled with the expectation of that. Full stop. He is starting to play better and I think he will steadily improve. Attacking his personal qualities is not really called for.
Jesus, I’m questioning his ticker on the footy field. I’m not calling him a bad person... anyway moving on to next week.
I don't think we can and should compare injuries, especially contact with the head.
Everyone one reacts different when hit in the head. Some people can take an absolute beating and the brain will some how keep you on your feet in survival mode. Others can take a moderate hit and can go black, foggy and see stars. Medically he wasn’t able to come back.
We have enough injuries to contend with without adding concussions to the list and miss two weeks rather than the end of a game.
Golly what’s happened to the Forum tonight.
Lol lads made my day ... I can only think of Nate “inches not” Myles who would never have had an HIA with his melon.