Best player never to win a Dally M

Is Darren Lockyer the best ever never to win a Dally M or Rothmans Medal. Here is a few more names to through around, Mal Meninga, Wally Lewis played his best years in the QRL, Scott Prince, Benny Elias, Artie Beetson

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by broncosrule

Artie Beetson

---

Forwards never win.

except cameron smith two years ago...
-

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dummy Half

except cameron smith two years ago...
-

---

Forwards(excepting hookers of course) if you want to get caught up in semantics?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wikipedia

The Dally M Awards is an awards night which aims to honour the finest players each year in the Australian National Rugby League competition. The awards were introduced in 1980 by News Limited. The most prestigious of these awards is the Dally M Medal and for rookies (Dally M Rookie Of the year) it is awarded to the Player Of The Year. As well as honouring the player of the year, the awards night also recognises the premier player in each position, the best coach, the best captain, representative player of the year and the most outstanding rookie of the season. The awards are named in honour of former Australian rugby league great Herbert Henry "Dally" Messenger.

News Limited journalists vote on the best performing players in each match on a 3, 2, 1 points system. The scores of the voting are visible to the public and media up until Round 16 of the NRL season. In 1998, following the merger of the Super League and the Australian Rugby League (ARL), the awards were re-introduced as the official awards of the newly formed National Rugby League. Prior to 1998, the official award of the game was voted on by the referees. These awards were known as the Rothmans Medal from 1968-1996 and the Nokia Provan-Summons Medal in 1997.

Between 1980 and 1996, when both the Dally M Medal and Rothmans Medal were awarded, the same player won both awards on only three occasions - Peter Sterling in 1987, Gavin Miller in 1989 and Ricky Stuart in 1993.

In 1997, when the game was split between the News Limited-organized Super League competition and the ARL, News Limited did not hold the awards.

The only other time the awards night has not been held was in 2003. Due to a dispute with the Rugby League Players Association, the NRL cancelled the Dally M awards two days prior to the ceremony. Previously, the players had threatened to boycott the event unless the NRL met their demands.

---

1980
Robert Laurie, South Sydney

1981
Steve Rogers, Cronulla Sharks

1982
Ray Price, Parramatta Eels

1983
Terry Lamb, Western Suburbs Magpies

1984
Michael Potter, Bulldogs

1985
Greg Alexander, Penrith Panthers

1986
Peter Sterling, Parramatta Eels

1987
Peter Sterling, Parramatta Eels

1988
Gavin Miller, Cronulla Sharks

1989
Gavin Miller, Cronulla Sharks

1990
Cliff Lyons, Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles

1991
Michael Potter, St. George

1992
Gary Freeman, Roosters

1993
Ricky Stuart, Canberra Raiders

1994
Cliff Lyons, Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles

1995
Laurie Daley, Canberra Raiders

1996
Allan Langer, Brisbane Broncos

1998
Andrew Johns, Newcastle Knights

1999
Andrew Johns, Newcastle Knights

2000
Trent Barrett, St George Illawarra Dragons

2001
Preston Campbell, Cronulla Sharks

2002
Andrew Johns, Newcastle Knights

2003
No Dally M Awards...

2004
Danny Buderus, Newcastle Knights

2005
Johnathan Thurston, North Queensland Cowboys

2006
Cameron Smith, Melbourne Storm

2007
Johnathan Thurston (Cowboys)

wow...in the last 15 years, only the two hookers (Smith and Buderus) were the only non-halves to receive the Dally M.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chaos

wow...in the last 15 years, only the two hookers (Smith and Buderus) were the only non-halves to receive the Dally M.

---

i personally think that forwards should receive more points ..... im just giving Laffranchi as an example (not saying he deserves to win cause there are a lot of forwards that do)
but common ......691 tackles, 245 hit-ups, 12tries (most tries for our team)

to Matt Orford

285 tackles 1 hit-up 2 tries

Now according to that who has done more work this yr :eyebrows:

and again im not saying Laffranchi should have won ...i could take most forwards in the comp and compare them to the backs ....i just think for all the work they do they dont get a chance at the final reward!

i liked B.Slater when he was asked who would you have given you points to in your final game and he said i think i would give it to a forward like either B.White or J.Lima, because without those boys we would not be able to do what we do...........what a CHAMP!